| 1978-79: 31st Annual Allegany County League Class B-C Wrestling Championships (Feb 17, 1979) |
| 1977-78: 30th Annual Allegany County League Class B-C Wrestling Championships (Feb 18, 1978) |
| 1976-77: 29th Annual Allegany County League Class B-C Wrestling Championships (Feb 19, 1977) |
| 1975-76: 28th Annual Allegany County League Class B-C Wrestling Championships (Feb 21, 1976) |
| 1974-75: 27th Annual Allegany County League Class C Wrestling Championships (Feb 15, 1975) |
| 1973-74: 26th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 23, 1974) |
| 1972-73: 25th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 24, 1973) |
| 1971-72: 24th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 26, 1972) |
| 1970-71: 23rd Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 20, 1971) |
| 1969-1970: 22nd Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 28, 1970) |
| 1968-69: 21st Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 22, 1969) |
| 1967-68: 20th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 17, 1968) |
| 1966-67: 19th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 18, 1967) |
| 1965-66: 18th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 19, 1966) |
| 1964-65: 17th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 20, 1965) |
| 1963-64: 16th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 22, 1964) |
| 1962-63: 15th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 23, 1963) |
| 1961-62: 14th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 22, 1962) |
| 1960-61: 13th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 21, 1961) |
| 1959-1960: 12th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 20, 1960) |
| 1958-59: 11th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 21, 1959) |
| 1957-58: 10th Annual Allegany County League Class C-D Wrestling Championships (Feb 22, 1958) |
| 1956-57: 9th Annual Allegany County League Class B Wrestling Championships (Feb 14, 1957) |
| 1955-56: 8th Annual Allegany County League Class B-C-D Wrestling Championships (Mar 3, 1956) |
| 1954-55: 7th Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 9, 1955) |
| 1953-54: 6th Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 22, 1954) |
| 1953-54: Allegany County Section I Wrestling Championships (Mar 15, 1954) |
| 1952-53: 5th Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 16, 1953) |
| 1951-52: 4th Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 17, 1952) |
| 1950-51: 3nd Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 12-14, 1951) |
| 1949-1950: 2nd Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 22-23, 1950) |
| 1948-49: 1st Annual Allegany County League Wrestling Championships (Mar 26, 1949) |
