| 1999-2000: 23rd Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 29, 1999) |
| 1998-99: 22nd Annual Newfane Holiday Varsity Tournament (Dec 29, 1998) |
| 1997-98: 21st Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Jan 2-3, 1998) |
| 1996-97: 20th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Jan 3-4, 1997) |
| 1995-96: 19th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 27, 1995) |
| 1994-95: 17th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 28, 1994) |
| 1992-93: 16th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Jan 2, 1993) |
| 1985-86: 8th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 28, 1985) |
| 1984-85: 7th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 22, 1984) |
| 1983-84: 6th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 27, 1983) |
| 1982-83: 5th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 28, 1982) |
| 1981-82: 4th Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 29, 1981) |
| 1980-81: 3rd Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 30, 1980) |
| 1979-1980: 2nd Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 27, 1979) |
| 1978-79: 1st Annual Newfane Holiday Wrestling Tournament (Dec 30, 1978) |
