| 1969-1970: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 31, 1970) |
| 1964-65: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Feb 11, 1965) |
| 1954-55: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Mar 2, 1955) |
| 1947-48: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 16, 1948) |
| 1946-47: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Mar 14, 1947) |
| 1932-33: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 19, 1933) |
| 1931-32: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Feb 23, 1932) |
| 1931-32: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 12, 1932) |
| 1928-29: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Mar 5, 1929) |
| 1928-29: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Feb 13, 1929) |
| 1926-27: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Feb 23, 1927) |
| 1926-27: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 12, 1927) |
| 1925-26: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Mar 3, 1926) |
| 1925-26: Monroe (Rochester) [NY] vs. West High (Rochester) [NY] (Jan 28, 1926) |
